That felt a bit rushed, didn’t it? I mean, I always appreciate how RPDR tries to keep its formatting fresh with change-ups, but there was a lot more time to watch the queens interact and acclimate when season 8 premiered. That’s my feeling anyways. Between a guest superstar and a lot of focus on design and runway, there was plenty to take in, just not a lot of breathing room for the show’s nicer in-between, magic moments that give RPDR a lot of its charm. That being said, plenty of material from episode one to judge a new batch of girls on so let’s get to it (main challenge was a two-part pageant judged by Gaga and our panel of regulars). My power rankings from best to worst, especially relative this time because no one was sent home in favor of a last-minute-new-addition to the cast performed as a “cliffhanger” moment. Let’s go!
Nina Bo’nina Brown (winner) – My boyfriend will attest that I screamed and grabbed at his arm for every look she showcased this week. She got my jaded ass excited with her aesthetic, her nerve, her energy. I love when an entertainer makes me think “watch out” and she gave me that life. She’s smart too, if that snatched Gaga look for part two of the main challenge is any indicator, able to change it up without getting stuck in her wheelhouse. I’ll be looking to see her rise to the challenges of the season, including Michelle’s inevitable demand for more traditional glamour.
Sasha Velour – I love her commitment to pop art styling, avant-garde expression, and I get the sense she’s a real performer. From the prolonged shriek as her intro to the movement with fabric in her Gaga-in-Applause inspired runway look to the Warhol style self-portrait she held up during her Hometown category look, Sasha seemed to have a strong, unapologetic sense of she was and what she wanted to do. Whether she’ll have the versatility the show demands remains to be seen, but more often than not the true winners of the series’ past seasons have been able to inject themselves into every challenge they get thrown. Sasha has the promise of being able to do that.
Valentina – A big deal will be made out of her drag debut being so close to the show, but she obviously polished the shit out of her drag in private before any of that happened so I’m not buying that pre-made arc. I get why she didn’t quite make top three this week but every one of her looks this week was gorgeous, and she’s in contention for the best makeup in the house this season. Let her competitors underestimate because no way she isn’t hungry for this. I’ll probably have to acknowledge a bias for her from next week onwards because I love me a proud latina who wants to bring that identity to her art. I feel real kinship with that, sue me.
Eureka – A big girl I hope to see succeed on the level of Ginger Minj or Latrice Royale over the course of this season. It’s hard to say she wasn’t on the level of the queens above her in all honesty, it was just splitting hairs. I will say that she might have showcased her versatility better than anyone, doing a full-on John Waters comedic moment for her Hometown category and then showing up ultra-put-together in her Gaga-Telephone look. Her entry look and attitude were great too. She’s clearly not scared to be there, which has been a downfall of many a girl on this show to come before her. She told Valentina she’d eat her and I get the sense the whole cast better watch out that she not do the same while underestimating her with the usual boring fat jokes. Also, how cute was her breaking down over Gaga in the workroom?
Peppermint – I’m giving lots of points for personality with this one, she’s really got a gregariousness that will get her to stand out from the pack. What she’s going to have to watch out for is making sure she’s giving the full package at all times. She’s got good makeup skills, good clothing, but the styling details were a bit off (as the judges noted in her Gaga/Bowie look). Not to mention her wig-lines were easy to clock off of both looks she rocked in the pageant, which worries me a tad. Still I’m loving her charisma, I’m believing that she gets people energized at her shows like she claimed. C’mon candy gurl!
Alexis Michelle – She’s so polished and her painting style reminds me of Roxxxy Andrews in a really good way, but I have to admit I didn’t really notice her fully until her Gaga-Golden-Globes moment where her Broadway training really showed up as she “accepted her award” looking so correct and giving a subtle camp that’s hard to do. That being said her Hometown look was a little muddy around the bodice (I liked the idea of shouting out civil rights though) and I felt like I’ve seen her entrance look on other queens past to the letter. That worries me a little bit. I’m ready to see more from her, I’m ready to see her push herself to that level she’s demonstrated she can reach.
Aja – Let’s just get it out of the way: the painting is rough, she really needs to think about her makeup skills going forwards if she wants to stay in the race. But I see high-fashion clothes (that Commes des Garcon homage to Gaga was the right move), good hair, and most importantly a willingness to take risks and surprise. Plus, Sasha Velour mentioned that Aja is an it name in Brooklyn at the moment so I’ll be interested to see how she brings that to the RPDR stage. She’s got big shoes to fill based on the Brooklyn queens of Season 8. I didn’t love her talking up her wardrobe to everyone though. As Kimora Blac said: “No one cares!” Make us care, bitch. Make us care.
Shea Coulee – As a Chicago native I was LIVING for her campy costume for the Hometown category showcasing our signature style of hot dogs! Hilarious and thoughtful and I totally got from her looks and attitude the “champagne dreams on a lemonade budget” vibe she promised us in her intro sound byte. That’s also her con though because once again I felt the painting was pretty rough (that cheek contour left something to be desired, right? same with those cliffhangers in the entrance look?) and I had to struggle and rematch to even remember her meh-execution Gaga outfit so that’s… not the best. I hope she can bring more of her strengths to light next week.
Charlie Hides – I don’t know with this one…. I really enjoy something about her character, but I don’t feel like we’ve seen even close to what she can do yet. Her entrance look was real cute, but then she struggled with her Hometown look’s reveal/tear-away aspect, which she should have had down if she was going to do it at all. The judges really seemed to respond to her Gaga look, which I’ll admit went for it in terms of scope, I just don’t know if it got all the way there in terms of execution. Just little snags all over the place that kept her out of the top of the pack this week. She claims to be a celebrity impersonator so maybe that had me holding her to a higher standard? I don’t know, I’m confused by her and maybe that’s a big element of why I’d like to see her continue? I’m lost with this one.
Kimora Blac – My fave of the self-proclaimed body queens this seasons so far. Drag is exaggeration to me, and so I love her insane padding and her over-the-top attitude. I do think there’s a slight risk of the judges finding her too generic? That already seemed to be a critique of her Hometown look, but representing Vegas in one look is no easy task. She’s very put together in general though so hopefully she just brings more of the personality from her sound bytes into her actual presentation and performances for the judges to review. She strikes me as smart and seasoned too, so I’m grading her up a little for that.
Farrah Moan – I was expecting so much when she showed up in the workroom giving me Jessica Rabbit, down, BOOTS. Then her Vegas look was kind of heavy, if in the spirit of Vegas costumery to my eye (fuck what the judges were blathering about in this case). I also loved that she used her actual hair for her Gaga-in-Alejandro fantasy (also a bit heavy in silhouette though, as judges pointed out). The makeup was stunning every time, I just want so much more from her in weeks to come or she’ll just keep sliding down the rankings for me. It’s a wild bunch of gals this year, she’s going to need to stand out and soon. There’s not much time, you know? Get to it.
Trinity Taylor – She’s this far down because she talked a big game in sound bytes, but I saw nothing remarkable or memorable this week. Claims she’s a body queen? Okay, cool, what else. Claims she’s a pageant girl? Again, cool, but nothing to write home about. And then her Hometown look from Orlando was so convoluted and iffy for me, followed by a Gaga-in-Horror-Story look that was the closest she got to me remembering her. I’m not trying to read, but she’s making it so easy. Do more or go home.
Jaymes Mansfield – Poor thing, I’m just sensing a lot of desperation from her already. She claims to be a comedy queen but I never really laughed at any of her efforts. I wanted to. What was with that busted puppet in her entrance bit? And how did all three of her looks give such a similar silhouette despite being different to some extents? Was it how cheap they all looked? Quite possibly. I’m getting Mimi Imfurst, Sasha Belle and other early elimination try-hards from her. It’s not a good sign when I’m holding your alleged strengths against you, like I did when she tried to camp up her Gaga-in-Vogue moment. That was a chance to be snatched that she totally missed by deciding to act inexplicably sedated? Not feeling it, sorry ‘bout it. Not that sorry though.
Okay, I’ve had it. Officially. See you next week.